Sholom Asch and Divine Democracy

From Sholom Asch, What I Believe, Putman, New York, 1941
Dedicated to Fr. Brent Keith, Messiah the King CEC, Selma, AL

PicoSearch
  Help
Site Search by PicoSearch


Jackson Snyder Monthly Viewsletter

Paul-Nison-Raw-Life-button

 

(10/21/04)

|


 

 

 

[NOTE: Asch's books are hard to find these days - but if you can find The Nazarene or The Apostle on the used market, they will really change your thinking about the life and customs of the men and women who preceded us in the journey.  jhs]

Luke 18:9. Yahshua spoke the following parable to some people who prided themselves on being upright and despised everyone else, 10. “Two men went up to the Temple to pray, one a Pharisee, the other a tax collector. 11. The Pharisee stood there and said this prayer to himself, ‘I thank you, Elohim, that I am not grasping, unjust, adulterous like everyone else, and particularly that I am not like this tax collector here. 12. I fast twice a week; I pay tithes on all I get.’  13. The tax collector stood some distance away, not daring even to raise his eyes to heaven; but he beat his breast and said, ‘El, be merciful to me, a sinner.’ 14. This man, I tell you, went home again justified; the other did not. For everyone who raises himself up will be humbled, but anyone who humbles himself will be raised up.”

Romans 5:17-19. It was by one man’s offence that death came to reign over all, but how much greater the reign in life of those who receive the fullness of grace and the gift of saving justice, through the one man, Yahshua Messiah. 18. One man’s offence brought condemnation on all humanity; and one man’s good act has brought justification and life to all humanity. 19. Just as by one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, so by one man’s obedience are many to be made upright.

 

Justification

   These two men, a rabbi and a tax collector, went into the Temple court to pray.  The reason for them being there and doing that was so that each might be justified before the Heavenly Judge.  The word “justify” is very important to our faith, and it means, “To free a person of the guilt and penalty attached to grievous sin.”  Paul defines justification as “saving justice.”  As disobedient creatures, we must seek out and find our justification before Yahweh if we’re to be saved from a wretched end.  Again, Paul reminds us that,

Romans 5:18. When one man sinned, all mankind became condemned. But, in the same way, through one man came an act of righteousness. It could bring life and make all men right with G-d.  (Simple English)

Of course, the “one” man herein spoken of was Adam, and the second man, Yahshua. 

1 Corinthians 15:22For as in Adam all die, so also in [Yahshua] shall all be made alive. 45.  Thus it is written, “The first man Adam became a living soul,” but the last Adam, a life-giving spirit.

  Let us seek complete justification – that our guilt might be washed away – that our record might be expunged – that we might go forward to perfection in the body of the life-giving spirit, Yahshua.

 

The Pharisee

   Look at how the Pharisaical rabbi tried to justify himself before the Heavenly Judge.  He spoke to Yahweh, comparing his good deeds to those of a man across the room – a tax collector – the agent of Rome.  The rabbi saw this man as the chief of sinners, a traitor to the nation, a collaborator and profligate – and he thanked G-d that he was so wonderfully righteous in comparison.  He reminded the Judge that he’d never been greedy, adulterous or unfair, as everyone else had, especially that tax collector.  After all, shouldn’t the rabbi be rewarded with justification since he paid his tithes and fasted twice a week?  “Aren’t I good boy, Yahweh?” he asked as he stuck in his thumb and pulled out a plumb.  Although his works were good, the Pharisee was neglectful of the weightier matters of the law.  While the outside of the cup sparkled, inside were cucarachas, maggots and decaying flesh.  The Pharisee was only fooling himself – he would not be saved.


The Tax Collector

   On the other side of the room, the odious tax collector beat himself up in anguish for his sins. 

“And though I be unworthy (x) through my manifold sins to offer thee any sacrifice, yet I beseech thee to accept this my bounden duty and service, not weighing my merits, but pardoning my offenses.”

He admitted everything, holding nothing back.  He threw himself upon the mercy of the Judge, begging to be sent forth from that holy place as a changed man – justified – pardoned – cleansed – saved.

   Yahshua tells his hearers that it was the sinner who was freed from not only his guilt but also his penalty – a death sentence.  The Judge reveals himself to be very shrewd and discerning; he’s able to distinguish not only the haughty from the sincere, but also sincerity from insincerity. 

 

You Choose

   St, John tells us,

1 John 1: 8,9.  If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, and will forgive our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

To put it another way, the rabbi, in trying to excuse himself by proclaiming his good works and upright character in comparison with the low-downer across the room, pronounced sentence on himself.  “For the wages of sin is death (Romans 6:23).   Yahweh is merciful and compassionate, but he’s also smart enough to know what dwells within each man.  “For everyone who raises himself up will be humbled, but anyone who humbles himself will be raised up.”  As it turned out, one sinner’s repentance was a greater work unto justification and salvation than all the good works of the Pharisee put together.

   Now when we remember the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector, we’re psychologically forced to put ourselves in the place of one or the other: that of the saint who is rejected or the sinner who is accepted.  Although most want to think we’re somewhere in between, there isn’t that choice – it’s one or the other, my friend.  Or maybe it’s both at once.

 

Sholom Asch[1]

   I use this parable to introduce an essay I discovered this week written by Sholom Asch in 1941.  Born in Poland in 1880 and raised in an intensely Jewish environment, Asch acquired an excellent Hebrew education.  He became a United States citizen in 1914 and a patriot for his adopted nation.   As his career in writing about Jewish life flourished, many of his readers began to wonder just what kind of Jew Asch really was.  Why?  Because he wrote favorable biographies of Yahshua, of Mary, and of “The Apostle,” right along with more “Jewish” kinds of characters.

   I discovered Sholom Asch this week in a book that’d been lying on someone’s shelf for sixty years.  As I read, I was struck by this man’s patriotism, faith and politics, and the fact that the world situation of 1941 that he wrote of was so similar to that of today.  So with your permission, the remainder of this message will express his lost thoughts – thoughts that I hope will encourage you to do what’s right though not necessarily expedient in the days ahead as you seek your own justification before the bar of the Heavenly Court.

   Sholom Asch writes:

 

Man’s Sin[2]

   We have all sinned. We are all guilty in the calamity that has come upon us. We have all contributed to the elevation of the demon of evil to the throne of G-d. Have we Jews lived according to all the prescriptions thoughtfully provided by our wise men ..., or according to the ethical concepts of the Jewish faith? Were we the holy people, the people of the election, which we were bidden to be, and which we persuade ourselves that we are? What shall I answer?

   We have commissioned our Rabbis to make a “settlement” for us with the Accountant on High, while we ourselves pursued earthly well-being as the highest good. It may be, indeed, that we have been somewhat more generous than others ..., simply because ... our common suffering has awakened in us a strong feeling of mutual responsibility as a means of self-preservation. But against this, we have been too [boastful], lacking in reserve and modesty both in our acts and in our contacts ...

   ... I have the right to address this question to the Messiahians [as well]: has Messiahian man ... lived according to this faith? Has he suffered, surrendered, died, and been purified in the spirit of Yahshua? Have the limbs of the Messiahian been the vessels of Messiah? How can Messiahian man lift his hand to do evil if he believes that he is a part of the suffering Messiah and the Messiah is a part of him?

   All of us must beat our breasts in confession. A great Day of Atonement must come over the world. Life must be remolded. Jew and Messiahian alike must turn back to the origins of faith. We must choose a path of which we can say with the utmost certainty that it is the good path. – G-d’s path – the only one to be followed. More than at any other time in our history we must be armed morally, so that every one of us may be conscious that he is a defender of those moral goods without which life is not worth the living. Our house must be put in order, and the order must be a just one, so that every one of us is prepared to lay down his life for it.

   Such a change within us, such conviction that we stand on the side of G-d, cannot be the result of ideals emanating solely from the intelligence. One ideal alone can save us – that which is [equated] with faith in G-d ..., There is no measure of justice other than the justice of G-d: for justice is truth, and there is one truth, and one truth only.

 

What I Believe

   (1) It is my deepest belief that just as I have a share in the G-d of Israel through my faith in Him, that I stand under His authority and am included in the promise of redemption, so my Messiahian brother has his equal share in the G-d of Israel, stands equally under the authority and is included equally in the promise of redemption: for he is a son of Israel equally with me. His faith has made him a son of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. My rights are his, and I have a share in his religious values as he has a share in mine.  Basing themselves on this concept of equality, the sons of every faith must justify themselves in [their] works. Man’s ladder to [Heaven] is a ladder of works.  ...

   (2) It is my deepest belief that man has been chosen by G-d’s grace from among all creatures. Apart from the intelligence, which nature has given to every creature, ... man alone among creatures possesses a heart[3] that is a part of the endowment from above. Through his heart man stands in mystic contact with heaven.  By means of his heart man can acquire intellectual and intuitive powers that are outside the competence of nature ...  G-d guides every individual destiny through the inspiration of the heart. This inspiration is given to each one, and not only to the elect, so that everyone may, in the exercise of his free will, reach to the higher reason ... of the holy spirit.  Each one of us can follow in the footsteps of Amos, abandon the flocks, and become a Prophet in Israel. I believe in the democracy of divine election; each one of us can become even a Moses.

   (3) ... It is further my profoundest conviction that democracy[4] – in the social system not less than in faith – is G-d’s especial gift to man and resides in the act of grace that G-d performed for man in choosing him among all creatures. Democracy is interwoven with faith and cannot be separated from G-d. In having been chosen by G-d we became the children of G-d: “For sons are ye of Yahweh Elohim” – all of us, and not just a few individuals.  Any other relationship between us and G-d or between ourselves would contradict the will of the divinity, and would be incompatible with all that has been given to the Jews by Moses and the Prophets, and all that has been given to the Messiahians by Yahshua and the Apostles. Democracy is “all the law fulfilled in one word, even in this: Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself (Galatians 5:14). This is the foundation that, together with love toward G-d, was given through Moses, the Prophets, the Pharisees, Yahshua of Nazareth and the Apostles. 

   “Love thy neighbor as thyself” does not mean that you must be mild in your dominion over [your neighbor]; it means that you shall not have any dominion over him. He is a son of liberty not less than you, and the relationship between you and him can be built only on a system that assumes the rights of all.  ... And as democracy is the will of G-d in relationship between man and man, it is equally his will in the relationship between man and G-d. ... The divine law was not given to the angels, but to us. It lies before us like an open book. The measure is in our hand.

   Hence I believe profoundly that there is no love of G-d without love of men. Service to mankind is in my view the higher service of the divinity. But service to mankind must not be seen in the throwing of crumbs to the poor; as we are equal in our faith in G-d, so we must be equal in our faith in man. We must work out a world order that shall rest upon equal distribution of labor and rewards. “The right to happiness” must not remain an empty gesture in our Declaration of Independence; it must be incorporated in the administrative duties of the state. It must be interpreted in the material sense to which men are bound by their nature: in food and clothing and shelter, in the care for the aged, in our regard for widows, for the sick and the weak. ... The inner security of our citizens must become the cornerstone of our independence and freedom; it must become an [unspoken] obligation ...; not because we regard social injustice as the most potent instrument of the devil, ... but because without that obligation our professions of faith are as empty as [gamblers’] oaths.  {Here 1 Corinthians 13:1-3 is quoted.}

   (4) It is further my profoundest belief that we must lead a life in faith; that is, we must become ... a holy people. We can be a holy people only in a pure, ethical life ruled by laws and commandments. But no commandments, though they have a thousand eyes ... can purify and sanctify us if the heart of man does not sanctify his life. The heart is a filter for all acts and thoughts. If the heart is sound, man knows that his highest joy is bound up not with [indulgence] and ... uncontrollable passion, but with purity, with modesty, and with restraint.

   There is no level of corruption from which man cannot redeem himself, by the exercise of his free will. Whenever he makes an effort at such redemption, he can be certain of help from above. For G-d’s act of creation was not single and unique; it is a continuity of relationship through the individual destiny.  I believe, therefore, that for every individual there [may be] salvation, no matter how low he has sunk.

Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die,” saith Yahweh Elohim, “and not that he should return from his ways, and live? (Ezekiel 8:23)

   The heart of man is bound with the divinity through the light rays[5] of divinity. To the darkest and most horrible retreats to which men have withdrawn from the divinity, a ray of the divinity penetrates. And for this reason we must never despair of a man, much less of a group that is temporarily lost to the divinity. However deep a group has sunk, we must continue to pray for it and help it with our ... sympathies. And no matter how deeply we feel that we have been wronged by such, we must exert ourselves to purify our hearts from bitterness.

   We were worms in our physical creation; we have become human in our hunger for the divinity. The drink of G-d ... has enabled us to mount the ladder of Jacob that rises from earth to heaven. If we will endure, and continue the upward path, we will attain to the true salvation of a world that stands under the authority of G-d through a single, universal redeemer.

   The renewal of faith in the divine force of our moral values as our sole hope in the darkness of our night is what I would wish to submit to a suffering humanity.  It is America, which has been saved from the worst terrors of the night, which has not been corrupted with the cynicism that has been the undoing of Europe; it is America, young and powerful, blossoming in the virginity of faith, which must become the leading spirit among the nations. It is America, the land which has taken me in, among so many other homeless ones, as a child of her own, which I would like to see as a “light to the Gentiles,” leading the world back out of the night into the authority of the one and only G-d.

 

   Thus ends the sermon by Sholom Asch.  It’s amazing that an American Jew wrote it over sixty years ago.  It’s so relevant for believers today.  We must go forth as a repentant and justified people – but not just that.  We must DO RIGHT in every situation.  We must SAY RIGHT in every conversation.  We must INTEND RIGHLY in every transaction – and we must THINK before we ACT: “Will what I say or do jeopardize my witness?  Disprove my claim to love my neighbor?  Demonstrate my will above what I know to be the directive of Yahweh?  Am I being what Yahshua would be?  Am I godly and righteous even in my secret times?  Do I prove my diligence before him even when no one else can see?  Or am I a Pharisee and a whitewashed tomb?  Am I bound for life or death?  For heaven or hell?  For justice for all or justice for a few?  Am I living as a real American, founded on the Commandments of G-d and the Testimony of Yahshua, powerfully exercising my right to a morally right opinion in this crucial time?  Am I?  Am I?   What kind of a Chr-stian am I before Yahweh?  A Pharisee who talks the talk but is an inward deception?  What will I stand up for?  Before his judgment bar, what kind of American will I prove myself to be?”

 

Our perfect and righteous heavenly Father,
This day guide and direct our journey.
Sanctify our steps and co-ordinate our thoughts.
Ever lead us in the ways of eternal progress.
Fill us with wisdom to the fullness of power
And vitalize us with your infinite energy.
Inspire us with the divine consciousness of
The presence and guidance of the seraphic [angelic] hosts.
Guide us ever upward in the pathway of light;
Justify us fully in the day of the great judgment.
Make us like yourself in eternal glory
And receive us into your endless service on high.

From “Three Prayers” © 2004 TheoQuest.org

 top


 

[1] Writer, born in Kutno, C Poland. He studied at his local Hebrew school, then moved to Warsaw (1899), where he wrote stories, plays, poems, and novels in Hebrew and Yiddish. He emigrated to New York City (1914) and began as a writer for Yiddish newspapers. His play The God of Vengeance (1910) enjoyed great success in Berlin, and several other plays were later produced in the Yiddish theatre in New York. He continued his prolific career as a writer, occasionally in English, but mostly in Yiddish, and although he became a US citizen (1920) and had a home in Florida, he often lived abroad. Most of his works dealt with Jewish subjects, as in Mottke the Thief (1917) and Three Cities (1933). His most famous books (to English readers) formed a trilogy, The Nazarene (1939), The Apostle (1943), and Mary (1949), in which he attempted to portray Yahshua, Paul, and Mary in a way that bridged Messiahianity and Judaism, but he so antagonized some American Jews that he moved to Israel in 1956 where he died in 1957. © Crystal Reference 2003.

[2] From The Wisdom of Israel by Lewis Brown, Random House, 1945.

[3] The translator, Maurice Samuel, uses “soul.”  I have updated it to “heart” to keep the hearer from confusing Asch’s concept of soul with the Roman Catholic concept of “eternal soul.”

[4] Samuel uses the phrase “the democratic principle” throughout.  I have used the “democracy” to defuse any political rendering of these passages, or the notion that Asch is speaking of the Democratic political party of the 21st century.

[5] Or “radiations of divinity.”

 

Jackson Snyder (801) 605-1715  Vero Beach, FL